Thursday, June 1, 2023

My Experience on Quora

Sometime around November 2022, Quora showed up on my radar screen, as things tend to do, causing me to diverge from my usual routine and invest a lot of time into something unplanned. I actually signed up for Quora in 2011 and received a daily digest in my email which I enjoyed reading. Then out of the blue, I received an email from Quora suggesting that I set up my own space. It’s not that I am special. I suspect that tens or even hundreds of thousands of such emails went out to sleepy readers who rarely contributed answers. But it caught my attention as I was planning to increase my Internet presence in order to sell some books. 

So, I set up a space and started answering questions. I haven't made any money so far. But that wasn't really my goal. Monetizing is tricky and I would rather have a slow build than a spike. Further, Quora is in the process of making changes. It is better to be a prince with promise than a dying king. So, it is best for me to be patient. 

My goal was to get my name out in front of people to increase my book sales. I have figured out, after several months, that this may not be the best way to boost book sales. I am slowly realizing that you need to use Amazon's paid advertising in order to attract readers. Doing this is fairly complicated and it represents yet another hurdle to get over on my path to selling books. But, as I reflected on the time I spent writing answers to questions on Quora, I realized that even if I never make a penny on my space and don't sell any more books from my presence on Quora, it still provides a huge benefit. 

Writing answers for Quora is GREAT writing practice. At the beginning I answered 10-20 questions a day. So far, I have answered over 1,700 questions. My answers have received Over 92,000 views with 875 upvotes and 454 comments. This is not only feedback, but it is recognition and engagement as well. People will say that you should write every day and I agree with that. But what do you write about? With Quora questions you can answer questions about anything that you know something about. And you will find out quickly if you write clearly and whether or not people like your writing.

I started out answering questions on topics about which I have written books such as The Meaning of Life and Predicting the Future. Soon I drifted to answering questions about writing and lately I have answered a slew of questions about artificial intelligence. At one point a question popped up about ChatGPT which I was not familiar with. So, I got a few Kindle books and started answering ChatGPT questions as well. Many writers are concerned that ChatGPT will make writers irrelevant. And I have assured many on Quora that this will not happen. Granted writers will have to learn how to use ChatGPT. But it will not replace them. I have answered many questions from programmers who have the same concerns. Increasingly, people in customer service, law, accounting, medicine and finance are starting to see the threat as well.

When I retired three years ago, I was worried about getting behind in emerging technologies. But answering questions on Quora has kept me up to date and engaged. Not only have I refined my writing skills, but I have refined my learning and thinking skills as well. I do hope to make a few bucks at some point. But, even if I don't, it has been a great experience and I am glad that I stumbled on to it. 

And as an added benefit, I have sharpened my ideas on such things as whether or not AI presents any kind of a danger. It will almost certainly disrupt the job market although that is nothing new when it come to technology. But the fears the people have from watching science fiction movies like The Terminator are unfounded. I have watched The Terminator several times and have enjoyed it enormously. But, it  has not kept me awake at night worry about Skynet become aware.

I have figured out a couple things in the process of writing hundreds of answers on AI. First, there is fear that AI will eliminate all jobs. This is not true. AI will disrupt a lot of jobs and people will have to learn how to use AI in order to do their job just like they had to learn computer skills decades ago and how to use the Internet more recently. Second, many are  concerned about AI becoming sentient and enslaving humanity. AI will not become sentient. Our sentience is due to our biology which in turn is due to our DNA. We share 60% of our DNA with bananas. We share 0% with computers. So, it is more likely that bananas will become sentient than it is for computers to become sentient.

If you are interested, you can find my Quora space at https://DrJohnArtz.Quora.com and you can find my 1700+ answers at https://www.quora.com/profile/John-Artz . And while I am handing out urls, you can always find out more about what I am doing at https://DrJohnArtz.com .

 

 

 

 

Monday, May 1, 2023

Page Turners versus Magical Places

There are books for entertainment or distraction and there are books for learning and personal growth. Book reviewers seem to believe that the highest praise you can give a book is that it was a page turner that you couldn't put down. But is this really what you want from a book? Would you ever read a book like that twice?

Compare book reading to eating. Junk food is something you wolf down. It is like a page turner. Haute cuisine is something you eat slowly and savor. It is like a book that you read slowly enjoying the character development and unwinding of the plot. Is your book a big mac? Is it junk food for the mind? Is that what you want? If it is, then I am not going to tell you that you shouldn't enjoy such books. In fact, I will admit that one of my favorite authors is exactly that. I am not above enjoying either a junk food meal or a junk food book. What I am opposed to is writing pundits who suggest that the junk food approach of popular fiction is the only way to write a novel or a story. It certainly is not.

If you are reading junk food books it is like eating fast food hamburgers. You expect each to be predictably the same. That is what you are looking for and that is what the provider delivers. Nothing wrong with that. But, if you are eating at a high-quality restaurant, you would not expect each meal to be the same. In fact, you would enjoy the nuance and differences. If your book is junk food, then there is no point in rereading it. You already know what to expect. Rereading it would be like eating a cold hamburger. You really need a fresh hot one if you are going to enjoy it. But, if your book is haute cuisine, then you may discover something different with each pass.

 Here is another analogy. If you receive a catalog in the mail from a clothes vendor, you can leave through it and see if there is anything you like. On the other hand, if you are visiting an art gallery and you zip past the paintings the way you flipped past the pages in the catalog, you will miss everything. You should go through the gallery slowly and enjoy each painting at your leisure. You should go back several times and see the paintings again with new eyes. Would you keep a catalog so you could flip through it again on the anniversary of when it arrived hoping to see something new in it?

Bestseller books are often, not always but often, junk food for the mind. If it was a page turner and the reader couldn't put it down, then hat's off to the author. However, if the reader chooses to read it more slowly and think about it, that is a good thing as well. Perhaps the greatest praise you can give to a book is - I've read it several times and have gotten something different from it every time. What is going on with these two kinds of books? And can one book be both kinds?

 Well, the answer, I believe, goes back to the first line in this post. There are books for entertainment or distraction and there are books for learning and personal growth. Books for entertainment or distraction are more likely to connect with the reader emotionally. That is why, I believe, we hear so much about show don't tell. You want the reader to experience your book emotionally. They enjoy the experience and that is why they don't want to put it down. However, books that provide personal growth must connect with your reason. Why did things happen the way they did? What would you do if you were in that situation? These questions cause the reader to think. They are thought experiments that allow the reader to safely confront challenges that they might not otherwise experience. These books provide a magical place for the reader to get to know themselves.

Back to show don't tell. Show allows the reader to experience the book without thinking. But ‘show’ is not very efficient when giving the reader something to think about. If you want to feed the rational brain, you have to tell. And sometimes a lot of telling is necessary. Telling is more efficient and does not waste the readers’ time having to derive everything from the experience of reading.

Can a book be both? Absolutely. That, I believe, is what makes a truly great novel. The reader enjoys the experience of reading the book and is left with something to think about. But they can reread and enjoy a slightly different experience from a slightly different perspective.  And they can learn something new about themselves from the new experience.

Saturday, April 1, 2023

Professor? Oh, You Mean Me! - It Took A While to Get Here

 As it says in my profile, I retired at the end of 2019 after 27 years as an academic and 20 years before that in software development. I am now embarking on an encore career in which I plan to write. It is something I love to do. But this point was a long time in coming. Perhaps a little background is in order.

My first teaching job was at the University of Florida, in the mid 1970's, where I was a graduate teaching assistant. I don't recall how many courses I taught there but it was more than 6 and less than a dozen. And, I had a lot of really interesting experiences. One's perception of professors, adjuncts, or graduate teaching assistants is very different from the experience of being any of the aforesaid. For example, students in the class often feel that the instructor has all the power as they assign grades. However, with some rare exceptions, the instructor perceives the students as having all the power as they fill out evaluations and talk to other students and faculty. Further, the students often perceive the instructor as all-knowing whereas the instructor, especially adjuncts and graduate teaching assistants, often feel inadequate. This experience led me to consider writing a book to reveal this gap of perception. So, this was my first inspiration to write something almost a half a century ago. But, at this point, it was merely a dream.

About a decade later, the idea came back to me again. By then I had taught several courses as an adjunct at several different universities while working full time during the day. So, my first book attempt, started in the late 1980's, but never finished, was to be called Professor? Oh, You Mean Me. I had planned to write a memoir of sorts about my days as an adjunct professor. I thought it was a good idea because people who have never done adjunct teaching have no idea what it is really like. Sadly, I only got a couple chapters written. But I had realized how much I love to write. So, I didn't see it as giving up on the book. I saw it as postponing my writing until I had more time and a better idea.

Another decade later, I had already become a full-time academic and had written several scholarly papers. But writing scholarly papers is not fun and I wanted to write something fun. One of my research topics was the role of stories in computer ethics and it occurred to me that I should develop some skills for writing fiction that may dovetail with this other research.

So, I came up with an idea which was way too ambitious and started writing chapters which I emailed to some colleagues for comment. The title of the novel was Dybuks in the Portal and was based on the unworkable premise of some specially chosen spirits getting misdirected between lives and landing up in my imagination. I got about six chapters into it before I realized that I just didn't have what it took to make it work.

Being sufficiently chastened by my experience with Dybuks, I decided to try something in genre fiction which was a little more constrained. I created a detective named Thaddeus Wentworth and used Foggy Bottom University as a setting. This was more my speed. I, again, emailed the chapters out once a week to colleagues who read them primarily because the characters were based on people on the email list. The book was called Identity and I managed to finish it. I continued in this vein for two more Wentworth books which I finished but did not publish at the time. They were Along Came a Spider, and Confidence. All three of these are available on Amazon (see my website a DrJohnArtz.com ). 

I put Wentworth aside and wrote a manuscript which I called The Ghost of Socrates exploring philosophical issues in information systems. I made the manuscript freely available online and did not publish it until after I retired.

Then, as luck would have it, I got an opportunity to teach a Writing in the Disciplines course called Writing Stories to Explore the Ethics of Technology. This opportunity was a godsend, and I spent the next five or six years developing the idea and my writing skills for fiction. Much of the foundation work for Writing Stories to Explore Possible Worlds was developed during this time. Possible Worlds will be available in late 2023.

The first three Wentworth books were written in the late 1990's and early 2000's. I am currently working on a fourth called Hamartia which will also be out in late 2023. I have one more Wentworth book called Closure scheduled to come out in late 2024. 

Possible Worlds and Closure mark the end of my current phase of writing. I have some more ambitious fiction planned for the next phase. When people hear that I retired four years ago and will have ten books published in that time they think that is unbelievable. But, in reality, it took a lot longer.

Some people ask me if I love writing so much why did I wait so long to do it seriously. The answer is simple. I had bills to pay and a family to take care of. And the work I was doing and being well compensated for was not horrible. There are some jobs that I think should be pursued by people with more experience. I won't get into my theory about young people’s jobs and jobs for people with more experience. But I will say that putting off writing was a good choice for me. I don't have to worry about paying the bills. I have a lot more experience. And I have had a lot of time to read and think. So, here I am Lego, Cogito and now Scribo.

Wednesday, March 1, 2023

The Mythical Mind or Who are you writing for?

 In an earlier post on the Triune brain, I asserted that we have two brains, which I referred to as the Neo-cortex and the limbic system. These two brains result in two consciences and two interpretations of the world. I am simplifying things a bit as I am not teaching a class in brain science. Rather, I am laying some foundation for storytelling. For our purposes we can think of these two brains giving rise to two minds which I will refer to as the rational mind and the mythical mind. This is not exactly correct for reasons I will eventually explain. But, for now it is good enough. And I didn't just make this up. Jordan Peterson makes an observation very similar to this.

 "The 'natural' pre-experimental, or mythical mind is in fact primarily concerned with meaning - which is essentially implication for action - and not with 'objective' nature." [Maps of Meaning pg. 3]

The rational mind is concerned with what is 'out there' and what its properties are. The mythical mind is concerned with what we need to do about it. Our mythical mind has been around a lot longer than our rational mind and has been refined by millions of years of evolution compared with thousands of years for the rational mind.

Consider the following two options for an opening paragraph for a story.

Option 1:

Beth awoke at her usual time, made a cup of coffee, and began tidying up the living room. As she worked, she quietly sung to herself the Paul McCartney song, It’s Just Another Day. And indeed, it was. Just another day.

Option 2:

Beth awoke at her usual time, made a cup of coffee, and began tidying up the living room. As she worked, she quietly sung to herself the Paul McCartney song, It’s Just Another Day. Little did she know that it would be anything like just another day. Nor did she know that by the end of the day she would be wondering if her life would ever make sense again.

Overwhelmingly most people would prefer Option 2 as it suggests and anomaly in the pattern of life and our mythical brains are attuned to anomalies which they pass on to the rational brain to deal with. Or, in simpler terms, anomalies get our attention. 

The most famous line in the Wizard of Oz is when Dorothy steps out of the cabin and says, "We're not in Kansas anymore". To emphasize this the earlier part of the film was in black and white. But now it is in brilliant technicolor. OK! You have our attention!

The unexpected gets our attention while the slow (but not too slow) revelation of explanation keeps it. When somebody enjoys a story, it is because you got their attention and then kept it. Both are important. I wrote a post last month about tell don't show. Showing engages the mythical mind as it helps capture the emotions (i.e., the limbic system). But telling engages the rational mind (i.e., the Neo-cortex) by providing rational explanations. If you do too much showing and not enough telling the reader may lose interest in your book and certainly won't want to read it again. I know a lot of people who read a lot and often read a book more than once because they had forgotten that they read it. These are books that focus on emotional engagement but fail to engage the rational mind. They show too much and tell too little. Do you really want your book to be that forgettable?